GH Creep in a Freshwater Aquarium Explained: Why Topping Off Isn’t Enough & How to Prevent it

Many aquarists rely on topping off instead of regular water changes, or perform infrequent water changes. These practices, while convenient, can lead to serious problems, including "GH Creep" and the accumulation of other harmful substances in the water. GH Creep refers to the gradual increase in General Hardness (GH), measured in degrees of German hardness (°dH), in aquarium water due to the accumulation of minerals. This article explains why, comparing a theoretical ideal with a typical home aquarium.

Scenario 1: The Perfectly Controlled, Empty Tank 

Imagine a sterile tank with just 100 liters of water at a GH of 6 °dH and a KH of 3 °dH. Consistent water changes use replacement water with identical GH and KH values. Even evaporation is precisely controlled. In this idealized system, GH and KH remain perfectly stable because no internal or external factors alter mineral concentrations.

Scenario 2: The Real-World Aquarium 

A 100-liter aquarium is set up with substrate, hardscape, plants, and livestock. The initial water is a GH of 6 °dH and a KH of 3 °dH, and CO2 injection is used. Evaporation is addressed with dechlorinated tap water, which likely does not match the aquarium's GH and KH. Over several months, water changes become infrequent, perhaps once or twice a month, and GH and KH testing is neglected. Eventually, the water is tested and reveals a significant increase to a GH of 14 °dH and a KH of 7 °dH.

What causes this "GH Creep" in a real-world aquarium? Several factors contribute:

  • Substrate: Gravel, crushed coral, aragonite, and some plant substrates leach minerals. Limestone-based materials are particularly notorious for releasing calcium and magnesium carbonates, raising both GH and KH.

  • Hardscape: Sedimentary rocks like limestone and dolomite significantly increase GH and KH, especially in CO2-injected planted tanks. The dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid, increasing the solubility of calcium carbonate and accelerating leaching. Driftwood and some resin decorations can also leach minerals. Shells and coral skeletons drastically increase both GH and KH.

  • Fish Food and Waste: Fish food contains minerals, which are released as uneaten food decomposes and as fish metabolize. This adds to the mineral load.

The Problem with Topping Off 

Topping off only replaces evaporated water; it does not remove accumulated minerals or waste. Therefore, regardless of whether the top-off water has a higher, lower, or identical mineral concentration to the aquarium water, topping off alone cannot prevent GH creep. Even topping off with pure RO/DI water will not prevent GH creep, as the minerals are still being added to the system by other means. Topping off essentially acts as a weak partial water change, temporarily lowering GH/KH from their current levels, but failing to remove the accumulated minerals. As evaporation continues, the mineral concentration will still rise.

The Inadequacy of Infrequent Water Changes 

Infrequent water changes also contribute to GH creep. Even if topping off wasn't a factor, the absence of regular water changes allows minerals from the substrate, hardscape, food, and waste to accumulate.

The Solution: Regular Water Changes 

Regular and sufficient water changes are essential for mitigating mineral and waste accumulation. They are the only effective way to remove the minerals that cause GH creep and the other harmful substances that build up in aquarium water. These substances include fish waste (ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate), phosphates (which fuel algae growth), dissolved organic compounds, excess minerals, fish hormones, and potentially harmful metals. All of these negatively impact the health of fish and plants, even if the water appears clear. While managing mineral input from other sources (substrate, hardscape) can help, it cannot replace the need for regular water changes. Regular water changes are the cornerstone of a healthy aquarium.

Water Changes and Beneficial Bacteria 

The fear of disrupting the delicate biological processes, especially the beneficial bacteria, is a common concern. It's a misnomer to think water changes harm them; neglecting water changes is far more detrimental. Poor water quality weakens and kills these bacteria, leading to ecosystem problems.

These microscopic allies are crucial for converting harmful fish waste into less toxic substances, and they colonize surfaces throughout the aquarium—filter media, gravel, decorations—not the water column itself. This is a key point: water changes won't wash away a significant portion of the bacteria population. Beneficial bacteria, like fish and plants, thrive in stable, healthy water. They actually benefit from regular water changes, which replenish minerals, remove nitrates, and maintain a balanced pH.

The key to safe water changes lies in mimicking existing tank conditions as closely as possible. This means matching both general hardness (GH), measured in °dH, and carbonate hardness (KH), also measured in °dH. Sudden shifts in either can stress fish and bacteria. KH is especially important as it buffers pH, preventing harmful swings. By matching GH and KH, you're also stabilizing pH.

Matching temperature, GH, KH, and oxygenation ensures a smooth transition, allowing biological processes to continue uninterrupted. It's not the water change itself that's risky, but how it's done, which will be covered in another article.

Up Next: A comprehensive strategy for managing GH/KH.
Location: Canada

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Optimizing Water Changes: How to Manage GH/KH for a Stable Aquarium

Image
Maintaining stable General Hardness (GH) and Carbonate Hardness (KH) is important for a thriving aquarium. Regular water changes are the primary tool for managing mineral accumulation and maintaining balance, but the type of water used for those changes plays a key role. This article focuses on optimizing water changes using soft water or water that closely matches your aquarium's current parameters. We assume you are already familiar with the concepts of soft and hard water. For reference, soft water is generally considered to have a GH of less than 4 °dH. Addressing Higher Than Desired Hardness with Gradual Reduction Should testing reveal general hardness (GH) and carbonate hardness (KH) levels exceeding your target, especially if regular testing has been absent, water changes with softer water offer a suitable method for gradual adjustment. While higher hardness may not present an immediate issue for all species, achieving the intended parameters often remains the goal. Importan...
Read more
Image
In this blog I provide guidance on improving your soft tap water by adding essential minerals and, importantly, how to avoid the steady increase in these minerals due to evaporation and other contributing factors over time. I also help you understand your aquarium's GH and KH, going beyond basic water change advice. General Hardness (GH) and Carbonate Hardness (KH): Are you testing for them in your planted aquarium? If not, you might be overlooking two of the most important yet often least understood water parameters. The Practical Aquarist is dedicated to bringing GH and KH into the spotlight and providing clear guidance on understanding, testing, and maintaining these essential elements for a thriving planted tank. 6 degrees of German hardness (6 °dH) sits right in the sweet spot for many common freshwater community fish, which do well between 4 °dH and 8 °dH – and represents my target for optimal planted aquarium water. In these pages, I focus specifically on using soft tap wate...
Read more

Understanding Water Hardness: GH vs. KH & Choosing the Best Water for Your Aquarium

Image
In this article, we will consider water. From pure water to soft and hard tap water, water hardness, and adding minerals to water. General Hardness (GH): The Mineral Content What most people refer to as "water hardness" is actually General Hardness (GH). GH measures the concentration of dissolved calcium and magnesium ions in water. These minerals are the primary contributors to what we perceive as "hard" or "soft" water. Higher concentrations of calcium and magnesium mean harder water, while lower concentrations indicate softer water. GH is typically measured in degrees of German hardness (°dH). Carbonate Hardness (KH): Buffering pH In contrast to GH, Carbonate Hardness (KH) measures the concentration of carbonate and bicarbonate ions in water. While KH is sometimes called "carbonate hardness," this can be misleading. KH does not directly contribute to the "hardness" in the way GH does (i.e., it doesn't make the water feel harde...
Read more